Wireless telephones and the risk of road crashes.
Laberge-Nadeau C, Maag U, Bellavance F, Lapierre SD, Desjardins D, Messier S, Sai;di A. · 2003
View Original AbstractHeavy cell phone users while driving face double the crash risk compared to non-users, showing clear dose-response relationship.
Plain English Summary
Canadian researchers tracked 36,000 drivers for four years, comparing accident rates between cell phone users and non-users. They found that cell phone users had 38% higher rates of crashes and injury-causing accidents, with heavy users showing double the risk compared to minimal users. This large-scale study demonstrates a clear dose-response relationship where more frequent cell phone use while driving leads to progressively higher crash risks.
Why This Matters
This comprehensive epidemiological study provides compelling evidence that cell phone use while driving significantly increases accident risk, with the most concerning finding being the dose-response relationship. The science demonstrates that heavier cell phone users face at least double the crash risk compared to minimal users, even after accounting for driving habits and mileage. What makes this research particularly valuable is its methodology - tracking actual phone company records rather than relying solely on self-reported usage, which eliminates much of the recall bias that weakens other studies. The reality is that this 38% increased risk applies to the radio frequency exposures from phones that were common in 2003, which were typically much higher power than today's devices due to less efficient network infrastructure. Put simply, while modern phones may pose somewhat lower risks due to improved technology, the fundamental cognitive distraction and potential biological effects of RF exposure during driving remain relevant safety concerns.
Exposure Information
Specific exposure levels were not quantified in this study.
Study Details
This research is an epidemiological study on two large cohorts, namely users and non-users of cell phones, with the objective of verifying whether an association exists between cell phone use and road crashes, separating those with injuries
The Société de l'Assurance Automobile du Québec (SAAQ) mailed a questionnaire and letter of consent ...
The relative risk of all accidents and of accidents with injuries is higher for users of cell phones...
Show BibTeX
@article{c_2003_wireless_telephones_and_the_2326,
author = {Laberge-Nadeau C and Maag U and Bellavance F and Lapierre SD and Desjardins D and Messier S and Sai;di A.},
title = {Wireless telephones and the risk of road crashes.},
year = {2003},
url = {https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12850065/},
}Cited By (242 papers)
- Phoning while driving I: a review of epidemiological, psychological, behavioural and physiological studiesInfluential
C. Collet et al. (2010) - 143 citations
- Driving and telephoning: Relative accident risk when using hand-held and hands-free mobile phonesInfluential
A. Backer‐Grøndahl, F. Sagberg (2011) - 105 citations
- Cell phone use and traffic crash risk: a culpability analysis.Influential
M. Asbridge et al. (2013) - 103 citations
- Mobile phone use by young drivers: effects on traffic speed and headwaysInfluential
G. Yannis et al. (2010) - 48 citations
- Relationship of Near-Crash/Crash Risk to Time Spent on a Cell Phone While DrivingInfluential
C. Farmer et al. (2015) - 45 citations
- Effects of Mobile Phone Use on Accident RiskInfluential
R. Elvik (2011) - 34 citations
- Cell phone conversation and automobile crashes: relative risk is near 1, not 4Influential
R. Young (2013) - 12 citations
- The Effects of Simulated Cellular Phone Conversation on Road-Crossing SafetyInfluential
S. Murray (2006) - 7 citations
- Linking data from different sources to estimate the risk of a collision when using a cell phone while drivingInfluential
F. Bellavance (2005) - 6 citations
- Les collisions en 1987 et en 1999 : comparaisons entre les personnes utilisatrices du téléphone mobile en 1999 et les toujours non-utilisatricesInfluential
Urs. R. Maag et al. (2006)