6,486 Studies Reviewed. 85.2% of Original Studies Found Biological Effects. The Evidence is Clear.

Human response to very low-frequency electromagnetic energy

Bioeffects Seen

Frey AH · 1963

Share:

Workers on the VLF transmitter tower experienced strong electric shocks and reflex withdrawal that could cause fatal falls, with fields up to 989,000 volts per meter at the ladder top.

Plain English Summary

Summary written for general audiences

Researchers measured alternating electric fields at a VLF transmitter site operating at 14.7 kc with 1100 kw radiated power. At the tower top center the field was 30,000 volts per meter and tingling occurred on bare metal and sometimes on painted metal. At the ladder top the field reached 989,000 volts per meter, producing strong shocks comparable to a 115 volts ac line and causing reflex withdrawal without muscle freezing.

Why This Matters

An aluminum hard hat drew a small spark when touched to bare metal at the 470-foot level, but the palm of the hand felt no unusual sensation at the same spot. The grill floor ten feet below the roof produced no noticeable sensations from radiation. Workers could not use bare hands on the top five feet of the ladder and climbed using only feet and safety belt.

Finding

At the top of the ladder, which protrudes about two feet above the roof, the ac field was measured as 989,000 volts per meter. All metal parts, painted or unpainted, produced a strong and unpleasant electric shock when touched — comparable to that which occurs when one touches a live power line of 115 volts ac.

In their words

“At the top of the ladder, which protrudes about two feet above the roof, the ac field was measured as 989,000 volts per meter. All metal parts, painted or unpainted, produced a strong and unpleasant electric shock when touched — comparable to that which occurs when one touches a live power line of 115 volts ac.”

Exposure Details

Electric Field
989,000 V/m

Exposure Context

This study used 989,000 V/m for electric fields:

Building Biology guidelines are practitioner-based limits from real-world assessments. BioInitiative Report recommendations are based on peer-reviewed science. Check Your Exposure to compare your own measurements.

A logarithmic frequency spectrum from 10 Hz to 100 GHz showing where this study's 14.7 kHz exposure sits relative to common EMF sources.Where This Frequency Sits on the EMF SpectrumELFVLFLF / MFHF / VHFUHFSHFmm10 Hz100 GHzThis study: 14.7 kHzPower lines50/60 HzCell phones~1 GHzWiFi2.4 GHz5G mm28 GHzLogarithmic scale
Cite This Study
Frey AH (1963). Human response to very low-frequency electromagnetic energy.
Show BibTeX
@article{human_response_to_very_low_frequency_electromagnetic_energy_g6646,
  author = {Frey AH},
  title = {Human response to very low-frequency electromagnetic energy},
  year = {1963},
  
  
}
No DOI on file for this study.

Quick Questions About This Study

The main hazard was reflex withdrawal from shocked metal objects, which could cause a fatal fall from the high tower structures where workers must maintain delicate balance.
Insulated gloves, such as those used by electricians, were found to protect the hands from the shock effect.
Workers mentioned the possibility of falls from reflex withdrawal but no such accidents were reported.