Complexities of sibling analysis when exposures and outcomes change with time and birth order.
Sudan M, Kheifets LI, Arah OA, Divan HA, Olsen J. · 2013
Cell phone exposure showed opposite effects in siblings born years apart, revealing how rapidly changing EMF technology complicates health research.
Plain English Summary
Researchers analyzed behavioral problems in over 52,000 Danish children exposed to cell phones before and after birth, comparing siblings within the same family to control for genetic and environmental factors. They found that cell phone exposure was linked to behavioral problems, but the association was strongest in first-born children and actually reversed in later-born siblings. This suggests that changing technology and usage patterns over time can complicate our understanding of EMF health effects.
Why This Matters
This study reveals a critical challenge in EMF research that often gets overlooked: how rapidly changing technology affects our ability to understand health impacts. The Danish researchers found that cell phone exposure appeared to cause behavioral problems in first-born children but seemed protective in later-born siblings - a biological impossibility that highlights how confounding factors can distort results. What likely happened is that cell phone technology and usage patterns changed dramatically between the birth years of older and younger siblings, making direct comparisons misleading. This underscores why we can't simply dismiss EMF health concerns based on studies that fail to account for the exponential increase in wireless exposure over the past two decades. The reality is that today's children face EMF exposures that are orders of magnitude higher than what earlier studies examined, yet regulatory agencies continue to rely on outdated research to set safety standards.
Exposure Information
Specific exposure levels were not quantified in this study.
Study Details
In this study, we demonstrate the complexities of performing a sibling analysis with a re-examination of associations between cell phone exposures and behavioral problems observed previously in the Danish National Birth Cohort.
Children (52,680; including 5441 siblings) followed up to age 7 were included. We examined differenc...
The association of behavioral problems with both prenatal and postnatal exposure differed between si...
Sibling analysis can be a powerful tool for (partially) accounting for confounding by invariant unmeasured within-family factors, but it cannot account for uncontrolled confounding by varying family-level factors, such as those that vary with time and birth order.
Show BibTeX
@article{m_2013_complexities_of_sibling_analysis_2728,
author = {Sudan M and Kheifets LI and Arah OA and Divan HA and Olsen J.},
title = {Complexities of sibling analysis when exposures and outcomes change with time and birth order.},
year = {2013},
}